The television landscape is currently dominated by the distinctive storytelling of Taylor Sheridan, a creator whose gritty, authentic narratives have captivated millions. While his flagship drama, Yellowstone, continues to be a cultural phenomenon, a new series from his expansive creative portfolio, Landman, is rapidly gaining traction and, according to an increasing chorus of fans, even surpassing the established titan. The recent drop of a thrilling preview for Landman’s second series has only intensified this debate, teasing more explosive drama centered on West Texas oil magnate Tommy Norris, powerfully portrayed by Billy Bob Thornton.

Landman burst onto the scene in November 2024, quickly establishing itself as one of last year’s most successful programs. The Paramount+ series, deeply rooted in the complex, often cutthroat world of West Texas oil territories, attracted an astounding 35 million viewers upon its debut. This impressive viewership not only set a fresh benchmark for the streaming service but also underscored the enduring appeal of Sheridan’s vision for American storytelling. Adapted from the Boomtown podcast and developed by Sheridan alongside Christian Wallace, the anticipation for Landman’s sophomore series is palpable, especially with the promising news of its earlier-than-expected return, with fresh episodes commencing Sunday, November 16th.

The upcoming installment promises a dynamic shift with Oscar-nominated Demi Moore stepping into a significant role as Cami Miller, following Jon Hamm’s exit from the program. Familiar faces returning for the second series include Ali Larter as Angela Norris, Tommy’s former wife, Jacob Lofland as their son Cooper, and Michelle Randolph as their daughter Ainsley. Adding further prestige to an already stellar cast is fellow Oscar nominee Sam Elliott, whose character remains identified solely as TL, though Tommy’s addressing him as “pop” in the new trailer hints at a pivotal familial connection. Elliott’s presence is particularly noteworthy, as he previously delivered an acclaimed performance as the hardened Pinkerton agent Shea Brennan in Sheridan’s celebrated Yellowstone prequel, 1883. Additionally, Grey’s Anatomy favorite Stefania Spampinato has joined the cast as a recurring performer, further enriching the ensemble.

Yet, it is the direct comparison to Yellowstone that truly elevates the conversation around Landman. The buzz among fans is reaching fever pitch, with many openly suggesting that the new series not only stands shoulder-to-shoulder with but potentially surpasses Sheridan’s original drama. Online forums and social media are rife with praise, with viewers like one YouTube user enthusing, “Hands down one of the best shows in recent years. Billy Bob Thornton killing it. Brutal yet humorous. Love it.” Another fan declared, “Oh snap this season looks even better!!! I’m hyped!!!” The sentiment that Landman is “next level” is widespread, with one reviewer chiming in, “This show is incredible…Taylor Sheridan is brilliant….I thought Yellowstone was great…but Landman is next level.” Echoing this, a five-star Google review proclaimed, “Move over Yellowstone…Landman is taking over!! Love it! I think the characters are great and it’s totally entertaining.” Another asserted, “This is far better than the Yellowstone series,” lauding its writing as “one of the best written shows ever. Dialogue is not only edge of your seat interesting—but witty, clever and not the typical ‘picture stretcher dialogue’ that’s filler until the next small dose of wit and humor as is the norm for long series. Excellent!”

These fervent fan reactions, while perhaps a testament to Landman’s fresh appeal, also compel a deeper look into the enduring power and pervasive influence of Yellowstone. The original series, centered on the Dutton family and their sprawling Montana ranch, has become a television phenomenon, redefining the modern Western. It masterfully blends the majestic beauty of the American frontier with the ruthless machinations of power, land disputes, and family loyalty. The character of John Dutton, portrayed by Kevin Costner, embodies a dying breed of cowboy, fighting tooth and nail to preserve his ancestral land against a tide of developers, Native American claims, and political maneuvering. Characters like the fiercely loyal and cunning Beth Dutton, the stoic and violent Rip Wheeler, and the conflicted Kayce Dutton have become household names, driving the narrative with their complex relationships, moral ambiguities, and willingness to cross any line for the preservation of their legacy.

What makes Yellowstone resonate so deeply with its audience is its unapologetic portrayal of American values—or at least, a romanticized version of them. It speaks to themes of tradition, family, and the struggle against external forces threatening to erode a way of life. The show’s stunning cinematography, capturing the breathtaking vistas of Montana, offers a powerful backdrop to its high-stakes drama, which often oscillates between tender family moments and brutal acts of violence. Its unique appeal has garnered it a massive, dedicated fanbase, particularly in regions that identify with its rugged individualism and traditional ethos, establishing it as more than just a show, but a cultural touchstone.

Sheridan, in his audacious vision, didn’t stop at one generation of Duttons. He expanded the Yellowstone universe backward in time, creating rich historical tapestries that explain the family’s origins and their tenacious hold on the land. 1883, featuring Sam Elliott in a career-defining role, chronicled the arduous journey of the first generation of Duttons across the Great Plains, depicting the brutal realities of westward expansion and the forging of an American identity through hardship and sacrifice. Its critical acclaim was immense, lauded for its historical authenticity and poignant storytelling. Following this, 1923 continued the saga, delving into the challenges faced by the Duttons during the Great Depression and Prohibition, further illustrating the family’s enduring resilience through eras of immense national upheaval. These prequels are not merely spin-offs; they are essential chapters that deepen the lore and emotional weight of the entire Yellowstone narrative, providing crucial context to John Dutton’s fierce protectiveness of his ranch.

The success of Landman in this context, therefore, is not a diminishing of Yellowstone’s legacy but rather a testament to the breadth and versatility of Taylor Sheridan’s creative genius. While Yellowstone explores the vast, untamed beauty of Montana ranching, Landman delves into the equally compelling, yet distinctly different, landscape of West Texas oil extraction. Both series share Sheridan’s signature style: complex, morally ambiguous protagonists, high-stakes narratives driven by ambition and survival, and a deep-seated connection to the land and its resources. The “far better” claims for Landman might stem from its focused, industrial grit, its distinct cast led by Billy Bob Thornton, or simply the novelty of a new narrative challenging the familiar. It offers a fresh perspective on American industry, power, and the ethical dilemmas inherent in the pursuit of wealth, mirroring the cutthroat nature of the ranching world but with a different set of tools and traditions.

Taylor Sheridan has firmly established himself as one of television’s most prolific and impactful storytellers. His work consistently explores themes of the American West, the struggle for land and power, the complexities of family loyalty, and the often-brutal realities of self-preservation. From the sweeping vistas of Yellowstone to the dusty oil fields of Landman, his universe is populated by characters who are deeply flawed yet undeniably human, grappling with universal dilemmas in distinctly American settings. His unique blend of neo-Western drama, sharp dialogue, and intricate character development has not only revitalized the Western genre but also created a television empire that continues to expand and captivate.

As Landman enters its second season, poised to build on its initial success and further solidify its place in the pantheon of prestige dramas, it stands as a powerful testament to the multifaceted storytelling prowess of Taylor Sheridan. Whether fans ultimately crown Landman or Yellowstone as their definitive favorite, one thing remains clear: Sheridan’s vision for rich, compelling American narratives is unrivaled, ensuring that the saga of his complex characters and the landscapes they inhabit will continue to enthrall audiences for years to come.