The air around Criminal Minds: Evolution is thick with anticipation, particularly regarding the potential return of beloved characters to the Behavioral Analysis Unit (BAU). Since the reboot first premiered in 2022, fans of the long-running TV franchise have harbored a fervent hope for a full reunion of their favorite profilers. The recent conclusion of the CBS procedural drama S.W.A.T. after eight seasons on May 16 has intensified speculation surrounding one fan-favorite actor: Shemar Moore.

For over a decade, Shemar Moore captivated audiences as Special Agent Derek Morgan on Criminal Minds. His portrayal of the strong, compassionate, and fiercely loyal profiler became a cornerstone of the show, forming an unforgettable dynamic with Kirsten Vangsness’s technical analyst, Penelope Garcia. Morgan’s departure in 2016, after 11 seasons, sent ripples of disappointment through the fanbase, as Moore opted to pursue a leading role in S.W.A.T. This career move, while understandable for an actor seeking new challenges and a different creative outlet, left a significant void in the BAU that many hoped would one day be filled again.

S.W.A.T., an action-packed series where Moore starred as Sergeant Daniel “Hondo” Harrelson, saw him leading an elite tactical unit in Los Angeles. The show, which offered a compelling blend of high-octane sequences and explorations of social issues, quickly garnered its own dedicated following. For eight seasons, Moore anchored the series, proving his versatility and undeniable star power. As Hondo, Moore embodied a leader who skillfully navigated the complexities of protecting his city while advocating for its diverse communities, often grappling with systemic challenges. The series was lauded for its timely storylines that addressed critical issues such as police brutality, racial tensions, and social justice, providing Moore a powerful platform to engage with narratives of significant contemporary relevance. Its cancellation, despite a passionate fanbase and often solid ratings, came as a blow, particularly to Moore, who had described S.W.A.T. as a “dream role,” marking the end of a significant chapter in his career.

The prospect of Moore rejoining the Criminal Minds universe is a significant talking point among his former castmates. Paget Brewster, who embodies BAU Section Chief Emily Prentiss, recently weighed in on the possibility. Speaking about the upcoming Criminal Minds: Evolution season 3 (which marks the 18th season overall for the franchise), Brewster admitted her uncertainty about Moore’s return. “I don’t know!” she stated, acknowledging the complexities of actor schedules and career paths. “That’s something that I have no control. I mean, none of us have any control over any situation… I don’t know if he would come back. I don’t know if he’s got another show. I’m excited to see what the future holds, but I don’t know if it’s with us.”

Brewster also shared her personal disappointment regarding S.W.A.T.’s cancellation, empathizing deeply with Moore and highlighting the emotional toll such an event takes on an actor. “I’m bummed out for him that S.W.A.T. was canceled, because that was his dream and it was doing really well,” she explained. “I know he was happy, and I know he’s stoic — but he’s hurt. It’s a heartbreaking thing to suddenly not be doing your show with your friends and this group of people that you support.” This sentiment underscores the tight-knit communities forged on long-running television productions, making cancellations not just a career setback but also a profound personal loss.

The idea of familiar faces returning to Criminal Minds: Evolution is not unprecedented within the franchise. The triumphant comeback of Matthew Gray Gubler as Dr. Spencer Reid, though still shrouded in mystery regarding his specific episode appearance in season 3, has already generated monumental excitement among fans. This success story serves as a powerful precedent for Shemar Moore’s potential return. Brewster herself offers a compelling parallel, having taken a hiatus from the franchise after season 7 before making a full-time return in season 12. “I was there for six years and then gone for four,” she recounted. “I did a bunch of comedies, and then I came back with no regrets. It was great for me, but maybe Shemar will be like, ‘You know what?’ I got it out of my system and want to return.”

The most crucial piece of the puzzle, of course, comes from Shemar Moore himself. In 2024, he publicly expressed his openness to reprising his iconic role as Derek Morgan. Speaking to TV Insider, Moore articulated his deep respect and gratitude for the foundations of his career: “All I need is an invitation. I never forget where I came from. I’ve gone back to the soap opera that started my career three or four times. It started with The Young and the Restless, and then it was Criminal Minds. And that’s my evolution. Without The Young and the Restless, there’s no Criminal Minds. And without Criminal Minds, there’s no S.W.A.T. If they asked me to come visit, I would definitely do that.” This statement not only highlights his loyalty to the shows that shaped his trajectory but also confirms his willingness to revisit his past characters, even if only for a guest appearance.

The television landscape is ever-evolving, with reboots and revivals becoming increasingly common strategies to capitalize on established fanbases. Criminal Minds: Evolution perfectly embodies this trend, allowing creators to delve deeper into characters and arcs with a modern sensibility, often exploring the post-FBI lives of its protagonists. The potential reintroduction of Derek Morgan, even for a limited run, would not only offer a nostalgic thrill for long-time fans but could also provide a compelling narrative thread. How would Morgan, now a devoted family man who left the BAU for a quieter life, react to the darker, more intense threats facing his former team? His unique insights and specialized skills would undoubtedly be invaluable in the current, more serialized format of the show.

As the dust settles on S.W.A.T., the future for Shemar Moore remains an exciting subject of speculation. His journey from the dramatic intricacies of The Young and the Restless to the psychological intensity of Criminal Minds and the action-packed realism of S.W.A.T. exemplifies a remarkable career progression. While nothing is yet confirmed, the expressed willingness from Moore himself, coupled with the open arms of his former castmates and the successful precedent set by other character returns, paints a hopeful picture for fans. The question of whether Derek Morgan will once again stride through the halls of the BAU is not just about a character’s return, but about the enduring legacy of a beloved actor and the powerful connections forged between television shows and their dedicated audiences. Fans, undoubtedly, will keep a keen eye on developments, eagerly anticipating what Shemar Moore’s next act will be, with many crossing their fingers for a meaningful reunion.